Data lake vs. Data warehouse
Data manipulation and management has become a necessity for businesses in today's age. This means that data needs to be stored somewhere in order to manipulate and analyze it. This is where the concepts of Data Lake and Data Warehouse come in. Data Lakes and Data Warehouses are used widely across many different industries to store and manage data. However, these concepts differ from one and other, providing different solutions for different business needs.
Data lake
A Data lake allows us to store structured, unstructured, and semi-structured data in a centralized repository. Data is stored in raw format in a data lake and is passed on to a data transformer layer to prepare the data for analysis.
Data warehouse
A Data warehouse lets us store structured data from multiple sources in a centralized repository. The data stored in a Data Warehouse is organized, processed, and optimized using
Key differences
Data structure: The data storage format is the key difference between a Data Lake and a Data Warehouse. A Data Lake stores raw, unstructured data, whereas a Data Warehouse stores structured, processed, and refined data.
Purpose: Data stored in a Data Lake usually doesn’t have a goal or a specific use case. Sometimes, it’s stored to keep on hand. Data stored in a Data Warehouse serves a particular purpose.
Users: Data scientists generally use Data Lakes because it is difficult for business professionals to understand and process unstructured data. Data stored in a Data Warehouse is processed and used in charts, reports, and spreadsheets, making it easier for business professionals to use.
Accessibility: The Data Lake architecture has fewer components and layers. This ensures that a Data Lake has very few limitations. On the other hand, Data Warehouse has a complex architecture, which makes it easy to decipher the data within but makes it difficult to manipulate the warehouse, making it more secure.
Security: Data Lakes require extensive security measures due to the vast variety of data whereas Data Warehouses can be made secure more easily. However, security of both Data Lakes and Data Warehouses depend on the security measures applied and the policies used.
Governance: Data Warehouses, with structured data, facilitate more straightforward data governance practices compared to data lakes. Here, diverse and unstructured data requires more effort in cataloging, metadata management, and classification to ensure governance and compliance.
Query Optimization: Data Warehouses are inherently optimized for complex SQL queries on structured data. On the other hand, Data Lakes with their schema-on-read approach and diverse data formats, necessitate additional query optimization efforts using tools like Presto or Apache Spark for efficient query performance.
Data Lake | Data Warehouse | |
Data Structure | Raw | Processed |
Purpose | Not yet determined | Currently in use |
Users | Data scientists | Business professionals |
Cost | Low | High |
Accessibility | Highly accessible and quickly to update | Costly and complicated to make changes |
Security | Difficult to secure | Easy to secure |
Governance | More effort required | Less effort required |
Query Optimization | Additional efforts needed | Inherently optimized |
Which one to use?
Both Data Lakes and Data Warehouses pose different benefits and key features. It depends on our business needs to identify the best solution. For instance, in healthcare, structured and unstructured data must be stored, making data lakes a more suitable option.
The key is to identify the unique business needs and analyze the differences between a Data Lake and a Data Warehouse to see which option suits us. Sometimes, businesses require both, and that is how the concept of a Data lakehouse was born.
Note: Data lakehouse combines the power of Data Lakes and Data Warehouses to satisfy unique business needs. Want to read more about it? Check out this Answer — What is a data lakehouse?
Free Resources